Buses, in some ways, are a throwback—not only historically, but in their simplicity.
Riding one today feels much the way it did as a kid. They rumble along, long and loud, with their hissing air brakes, no seatbelts, and the driver tucked into a cozy-looking cockpit. Even as New York embraces newer forms of transportation—electric cars, e-bikes, e-scooters—and as walkable cities become trendier, the bus remains a reliable way to get around town, in and out of the state, and wherever else we’re going. Safely, most of the time.
When buses crash, however, their size and weight can cause serious accidents that injure many passengers and other road users. Whether you’re already onboard, waiting to be picked up, driving another vehicle, or simply on your bike or on foot, the ubiquity of buses can mask their dangers. These are enormous vehicles—the size of tractor-trailers in some cases. It’s not always clear who operates them, and from a passenger’s vantage point, it’s often impossible to know what caused a crash.
In the aftermath of a bus accident, identifying what went wrong and who’s responsible can feel a lot like trying to decipher the rush-hour bus schedule in Midtown Manhattan. You sometimes have to act fast to protect your rights. And unlike buses, if you miss your chance to file a claim, another one might not come along.
Although it’s hard to believe, barely more than 100 years ago, the last horse-drawn streetcars were still transporting passengers around New York City. At the turn of the century, NYC relied on hundreds of thousands of horses for deliveries, transit, policing, and daily commerce.
But even before horses were officially retired from the City’s transit mix, the earliest motorized buses had already arrived. In 1907, the Fifth Avenue Coach Company launched the first motorbuses, transitioning from horses to gasoline engines.
Today, New York operates one of the largest and most complex bus systems in the world. Thousands of buses run on hundreds of city routes, carrying millions of riders each day.
Complementing the MTA’s enormous in-city fleet is a web of interstate and regional systems—including carriers like Greyhound and Peter Pan, the CTtransit I-Bus (Connecticut to New York), and NJ Transit (New Jersey to New York). There are also around 9,500 school buses in NYC alone, and more than 50,000 statewide, transporting over 2 million children per year.
Add in sightseeing buses, airport shuttles, university and employer shuttles, and charter tour buses, and the scale of New York’s bus system becomes even more staggering.
Buses can feel nostalgic, and with that nostalgia can come a false sense of safety. Many of us grew up riding them, continue riding them as adults, and associate buses with familiar routines and life stages. That familiarity can dull our awareness of the risks.
We might occasionally hear about a bus crash, but unless it’s catastrophic, it barely registers as a blip on the news. The next time you walk up the steps, pay the fare, and settle into a straight-backed, seatbelt-less seat, though, these statistics might give you pause:
A bus crash can sound like a fluke, but these statistics tell a different story. While buses crash less frequently overall, their crash rate per passenger mile is comparable to cars.
Part of the appeal of buses is that someone else is behind the wheel—you can read, listen to music, check your phone, or just zone out. But the following examples of recent New York bus crashes deserve your full attention:
| Bus Type / Region | What Happened | Outcome / Result |
| MTA City Bus (NYC Transit) | A pedestrian crossing a Manhattan intersection was struck and dragged about 20 feet by an MTA bus making a turn, suffering catastrophic injuries including paralysis. | Jury verdict: $72.5 million. |
| Private Tour / Charter Bus | A tour bus returning to NYC from Niagara Falls overturned on I-90 near Pembroke; several passengers were ejected during the rollover. | Five fatalities; dozens injured; NTSB and NY State Police investigations. |
| School Bus (Child Pedestrian Incident) | A 4-year-old child was struck and killed by a school bus near an elementary school in Jamestown, NY. | Criminal investigation opened; civil claims anticipated. |
| MTA Buses (Two-Bus Collision) | Two Q27 buses collided in Flushing, Queens after one driver reported brake problems; more than a dozen passengers were injured. | 14+ passengers transported; MTA investigation initiated. |
And while New York City and surrounding areas see their share of high-profile bus crashes, serious accidents also occur across the state, from Albany to Rochester to the rural stretches of the Thruway. Some recent examples include:
| Bus Type / Region | What Happened | Outcome / Result |
| Centro Bus (Syracuse) | A Centro bus swerved to avoid another vehicle and struck multiple parked cars in Syracuse; several people were evaluated for injuries. | Multiple minor injuries; local police investigation. |
| Highway Bus Overturn (Rochester / I-490) | A bus traveling west of Rochester overturned on I-490; all 28 passengers were transported to local hospitals, at least one critically. | 28 hospitalized; driver cited for fatigue, speeding, unsafe lane change, and not wearing a seat belt. |
| RTS Transit Bus (Rochester) | A vehicle rear-ended a stopped RTS bus in Rochester; the occupants of the striking vehicle were injured and transported. | Vehicle occupants hospitalized; RTS passengers unharmed. |
| CDTA Bus (Albany / I-90) | A CDTA commuter bus was involved in a multi-vehicle crash on I-90 near Albany, causing significant traffic disruption. | Minor injuries reported; multi-vehicle investigation. |
Taken together, these cases show that bus crashes don’t just endanger the people sitting onboard. The victims are just as often occupants of other vehicles, riders on other buses, or pedestrians and bystanders who never saw the danger coming.
The vehicles involved also cover nearly every kind of bus on the road—from city workhorses to regional transit fleets to cross-state charter coaches.
Talking about “New York buses” is a bit like talking about New York restaurants, or New York residents, or New York neighborhoods. We’re not talking one or two, three or four, or even five or six types, but an entire ecosystem of buses—public and private, local and interstate, city and rural.
Each type of bus comes with its own branding and features, as well as its own safety concerns, its own operators, and its own rules for bringing a claim. Understanding these differences can make a huge difference after a crash.
These include local routes, Select Bus Service (SBS), express routes, and articulated buses stretching the length of a city block.
Who operates them:
Common crash scenarios:
Potential liability:
Claims considerations:
A large portion of New York’s population relies on non-NYC transit systems. These agencies operate fixed-route buses, commuter services, and paratransit in urban, suburban, and small-city environments.
Who operates them:
Common crash scenarios:
Potential liability:
Claims considerations:
New York has one of the largest school-bus fleets in the nation (9,500 buses in NYC, 50,000+ statewide).
Who operates them:
Common crash scenarios:
Potential liability:
Claims considerations:
These long-distance carriers operate heavily on New York’s highway system and through New York City’s major terminals.
Who operates them:
Common crash scenarios:
Potential liability:
Claims considerations:
From double-decker sightseeing buses in Manhattan to charter tours in the Adirondacks, these buses span every corner of New York.
Who operates them:
Common crash scenarios:
Potential liability:
Many smaller counties and towns operate limited bus routes, senior transit, medical shuttles, or hybrid public–private services.
Who operates them:
Common crash scenarios:
Potential liability:
Claims considerations:
Understanding who operates the bus is only one piece of the puzzle. The next question most people have—usually the very first one—is who pays for their medical care after a crash.
In New York, the answer isn’t always obvious. Bus passengers, pedestrians, cyclists, and drivers are all treated differently under the state’s No-Fault rules.
New York’s No-Fault system treats bus accidents differently than ordinary car crashes, and the distinctions can completely change which insurance company pays your medical bills. The biggest surprise for most people: bus passengers usually don’t get No-Fault (PIP) benefits from the bus they were riding.
Here’s how the system works with respect to bus accidents:
Instead, your No-Fault coverage comes from:
This applies to city buses, school buses, and private carriers.
That means the bus’s insurer pays for:
This is one of the few times a bus company’s No-Fault policy applies directly.
This includes:
Don’t wait to initiate an insurance claim. It might be “your” insurer, but complications can still arise.
This means that:
The coverage isn’t always obvious:
Knowing these distinctions can prevent delays, denials, and missed deadlines.
Bus accidents are different from car accidents in almost every key aspect. They involve multiple operators, overlapping jurisdictions, and evidence that can be lost or overridden long before most victims even know what they should be asking for. The most important steps aren’t always intuitive—and missing them can close doors that can’t be reopened.
Here’s what actually matters in New York bus cases:
With buses in New York, the single most important fact is who ran the bus, because:
Many passengers have no idea who actually operated the bus they were on. Without knowing the operator, you don’t know the deadline, the insurance carrier, or even which laws apply.
Here’s what most people don’t realize:
No police officer or insurance adjuster is going to run to the depot and save your footage. Act fast, or risk having the most important evidence disappear forever.
Bus crashes often involve one or more of the following:
Reports from each agency can conflict—and in multi-victim crashes, they frequently do. Your case depends on identifying which agency wrote what, when, and why.
Depending on the bus, there may be:
A crash involving one bus can easily involve five or more insurers, each trying to push liability onto the others. This isn’t a fender-bender with GEICO and a claims adjuster named Flo.
Bus injuries can be deceptive because:
Documenting the injury progression is critical, especially in multi-victim cases where insurers will compare stories and timelines.
This is where the “another bus will come along” metaphor becomes painfully real.
If you miss:
…your claim may be barred even if the bus driver blew a red light in front of a dozen witnesses.
No amount of evidence can fix a missed deadline.
Bus litigation is its own beast. Anyone can write a generic “10 things to do after a crash” article; very few know:
That’s the expertise bus accident cases require. And that’s why this page—and Pain Injury Law—were created.
“I felt like I got hit by a bus” is more than a metaphor for the thousands of people involved in bus crashes every year. And you might feel like a “stranger on the bus” or stuck waiting for a missed connection if your claim isn’t handled by a law firm that knows the process better than a bus driver knows their route.
Push the button for your next stop: Pain Injury Law.
Answer a few simple questions to get started.
We assign a customized care team consisting of a lawyer, paralegal, and case manager to your claim.
Check in at your convenience to see how your case is going. Message your care team and upload documents right from your phone or choose another way to reach out and receive updates.
Our community is the driving force behind Pain Injury Law. For decades, our attorneys and affiliates have served as a lifeline to injured New Yorkers struggling to overcome the physical, financial, and emotional hardships that come with getting hurt. Meet the Client Care Team doing the actual work on your case.
All of the emails, paperwork, meetings, calls, court appearances… it’s all free unless we win your injury case.
All of the emails, paperwork, meetings, calls, court appearances… it’s all free unless we win your injury case.
Because getting injured is hard, getting legal help doesn’t have to be. To provide a secure and customized experience, Pain Injury Law uses cookies and tracking technologies. By clicking “Allow All,” you affirmatively consent to our use of internal session-monitoring technologies for security purposes, as well as the sharing of your device identifiers, web traffic, and audio-visual video viewing history on our public pages with third-party advertising partners. By making a selection, you acknowledge you have read and agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
